Are charity social media campaigns just playing on guilt?
Are charity social media campaigns just playing on guilt?
Opinion

#firstworldproblems
We’ve all seen the traditional charity adverts, the kind that tug at your heartstrings. They often involve a malnourished child, staring into the camera, appearing to be pleading for your help. Now, charitable giving is an incredible and essential thing but are the guilt tactics really necessary? Why are they used so frequently?
Firstly, it is important to acknowledge the importance of supporters to a charity. If a charitable organisation has a high number of supporters it is more likely to have a greater influence with government as more supporters mean more votes. This may then follow on to greater success in gaining extra funding or foreign aid for the beneficiary for which they are campaigning. Additionally, quite simply, more supporters generally lead to more donations and since most funds tend to come from the global North, this is key.
So, we’ve confirmed why a high number of supporters is fundamental for a charity. But how best to get them? It has been suggested that guilt tactics can be one of the most effective ways for marketers to draw attention to a particular tag line. As such, in framing a cause in a particular way charities are able to bring the issue onto the public agenda. An incredibly successful way of framing human rights issues, for instance, is through demonstration of bodily harm to vulnerable groups i.e. the malnourished child, which then naturally draws on feelings of guilt.
Indeed, as media has developed we have seen this method move across from the more traditional TV adverts and onto our social media feeds as well. For instance, one organisation jumped onto the popular #firstworldproblems Twitter hashtag to compare it to the real problems being faced in developing nations around the world on a daily basis, thus demonstrating that #firstworldproblems are not really problems at all and taking full advantage of the guilt framing tactic.
However, it appears that at long last we are starting to move across towards a more just method of campaigning. Charities are increasingly using social media to add a personal touch to their campaigns, taking a tactic that is more focused on providing a sense of achievement. Supporters are able to feel more connect with beneficiaries and see just where their money is going via regular updates and online videos. Furthermore, organisations are able to add an increased sense of legitimacy to their campaigns by showing the world they are doing on a day to day basis, as can be seen on Concern Universal’s Twitter feed.
So perhaps, in this ever-changing world, it would now be more effective to place a more positive emphasis on charity campaigns. Take a recent example of a charity that was shooting an advertising campaign with its beneficiaries and afterwards asked them to pose their own way and style the shoot themselves. The result was completely different with people proudly showing off their homes and mobile phones, presenting their achievements and success.
As a society, we are becoming increasingly immune to the traditional shock and guilt tactics used in the past. If instead we could see where our money is going and the impact our support has then maybe we would be more willing to donate.
Are charity social media campaigns just playing on guilt?
Opinion

#firstworldproblems
We’ve all seen the traditional charity adverts, the kind that tug at your heartstrings. They often involve a malnourished child, staring into the camera, appearing to be pleading for your help. Now, charitable giving is an incredible and essential thing but are the guilt tactics really necessary? Why are they used so frequently?
Firstly, it is important to acknowledge the importance of supporters to a charity. If a charitable organisation has a high number of supporters it is more likely to have a greater influence with government as more supporters mean more votes. This may then follow on to greater success in gaining extra funding or foreign aid for the beneficiary for which they are campaigning. Additionally, quite simply, more supporters generally lead to more donations and since most funds tend to come from the global North, this is key.
So, we’ve confirmed why a high number of supporters is fundamental for a charity. But how best to get them? It has been suggested that guilt tactics can be one of the most effective ways for marketers to draw attention to a particular tag line. As such, in framing a cause in a particular way charities are able to bring the issue onto the public agenda. An incredibly successful way of framing human rights issues, for instance, is through demonstration of bodily harm to vulnerable groups i.e. the malnourished child, which then naturally draws on feelings of guilt.
Indeed, as media has developed we have seen this method move across from the more traditional TV adverts and onto our social media feeds as well. For instance, one organisation jumped onto the popular #firstworldproblems Twitter hashtag to compare it to the real problems being faced in developing nations around the world on a daily basis, thus demonstrating that #firstworldproblems are not really problems at all and taking full advantage of the guilt framing tactic.
However, it appears that at long last we are starting to move across towards a more just method of campaigning. Charities are increasingly using social media to add a personal touch to their campaigns, taking a tactic that is more focused on providing a sense of achievement. Supporters are able to feel more connect with beneficiaries and see just where their money is going via regular updates and online videos. Furthermore, organisations are able to add an increased sense of legitimacy to their campaigns by showing the world they are doing on a day to day basis, as can be seen on Concern Universal’s Twitter feed.
So perhaps, in this ever-changing world, it would now be more effective to place a more positive emphasis on charity campaigns. Take a recent example of a charity that was shooting an advertising campaign with its beneficiaries and afterwards asked them to pose their own way and style the shoot themselves. The result was completely different with people proudly showing off their homes and mobile phones, presenting their achievements and success.
As a society, we are becoming increasingly immune to the traditional shock and guilt tactics used in the past. If instead we could see where our money is going and the impact our support has then maybe we would be more willing to donate.



Follow us on Twitter
